LATEST ARTICLES

High School Football: Results: Picks and Predictions for Week 3

0

EXPLAINING OUR PICKS: It’s Week 3 of the Pennsylvania high school football season, and the 4th Down Magazine team is here to tell you who’s going to win every game involving Mid-Penn Conference teams, as well as Schuylkill-Colonial League games featuring former members of the now-defunct Twin Valley Conference.

This year’s group of experts includes veteran reporters Andy Shay and Andy Sandrick, as well as 4th Down owner and manager Adam Kulikowski.

Here’s who we think will win each game this week.

2023 Standings

Picker: Week 3 — Overall — Perfect Picks
Andy Sandrik: 22-8 — 73-21 — 0

Adam Kulikowski: 21-9— 69-25 — 0

Andy Shay: 19-11 — 65-29 — 0

* Records in parentheses after school name; District and seed in parentheses before school name.

View our new podcast, 4th and Goal with Jake Adams and Andy Shay. This week, we’re chatting with West Perry wide receiver Ian Goodling. We’re also digging into what stood out in Week 2 including Big Spring’s victory over Shippensburg to claim the Little Brown Jug; our surprise team–the Bishop McDevitt Crusaders; plus we highlight an athlete to watch and one must-see game in Week 3.

FRIDAY, SEPT. 8

Altoona 35, Mifflin County 0

Andy Shay: Mifflin County 34, Altoona 20: Pretty obvious what the Huskies’ recipe for success is built around. Powered by an offensive line that is on point, running back Deakon Schaeffer is averaging 200 yards a game. Not sure Altoona can force Mifflin Country out of its comfort zone.

Andy Sandrik: Mifflin County 32, Altoona 24: Altoona will present a challenge, but the Huskies have answered the bell on both sides of the ball so far this season and deserve to be the favorites.

Adam Kulikowski: Mifflin County 27, Altoona 23: The Huskies are clearly trending up, coming off a 6-5 season last year. If the good times are to continue in Huskie Country, the defense will play a key role. One player that’s stood out in the early polling on that unit? Senior Owen Gipe. The 5-foot-10, 170-pound linebacker has racked up team-high 31 tackles to help limit MIfflin County’s first two opponents to 12 total points. 

York 42, Carlisle 40

Andy Shay: York 42, Carlisle 21: Not sure either defense is going to have a lot of say in this outcome, and it appears as if the Bearcats have more firepower in their offensive arsenal right now.

Andy Sandrik: York 39, Carlisle 35: Kulikowski and Shay can pick against Carlisle without hearing about it from everyone in the drive-through elementary pickup. I don’t have that luxury. 

Adam Kulikowski: York 39, Carlisle 28: Fun fact: the Thundering Herd have scored exactly as many points as they have yielded — 56. The result is a 1-1 record. 

Central Dauphin 35, Coatesville 13

Andy Shay: Coatesville 35, Central Dauphin 14: This will be the Rams’ second opponent in three games ranked inside the Top 10 in the state. Red Raiders’ defense has been impressive through eight quarters and will provide the biggest challenge to date for the CD offense.

Andy Sandrik: Coatesville 33, Central Dauphin 17: Vibes are getting better in Rams’ country, but knocking off this tough Coatesville squad is much easier said than done.

Adam Kulikowski: Central Dauphin 28, Coatesville 27: All signs say to go with the Red Raiders — 77 points scored versus just seven yielded; a victory last year against Central Dauphin; plenty of weapons in the cupboard. Yet, the vibe is back with the Rams and momentum can raise the tide to new heights. 

CD East 60, Northeastern 6

Andy Shay: CD East 35, Northeastern 7: There are huge matchup advantages all over the field for the Panthers in this one against a winless Bobcats squad.

Andy Sandrik: CD East 43, Northeastern 7: Even after a blowout loss, CD East is still about four steps ahead of Northeastern, in my book.

Adam Kulikowski: CD East 45, Northeastern 10: Losses to Red Land and Dover provide enough context to draw the conclusion that Northeastern doesn’t have the pieces in the proverbial cupboard to hang with the Panthers. 

Chambersburg 42, Waynesboro 20

Andy Shay: Chambersburg 42, Waynesboro 7: A friendly reminder the Trojans dropped half a century on the Northern Polar Bears a week ago. Enough said.

Andy Sandrik: Chambersburg 45, Waynesboro 10: I’m still stunned at how badly the Trojans gashed Northern last week. Something’s cooking in Chambersburg, and it would be unwise to pick against the Trojans right now. 

Adam Kulikowski: Chambersburg 34, Waynesboro 13: The Trojans have speed to burn, and that will provide plenty of trouble for a rebuilding Waynesboro squad. 

Spring-Ford 63, Cumberland Valley 17

Andy Shay: Spring-Ford 21, Cumberland Valley 17: Rams are 2-0 while the Eagles are winless after facing two high-quality opponents. This feels like a more level playing field despite the records. Path to success for CV lies in more help from the offense.

Andy Sandrik: Spring-Ford 24, Cumberland Valley 14: I know CV has played some really good programs these opening two weeks, but six points in eight quarters is still a red flag for me. The Eagles’ defense will keep this game close for as long as they can, but the offense is going to have to take that next step sooner rather than later.

Adam Kulikowski: Spring-Ford 17, Cumberland Valley 7: Coach Josh Oswalt’s offense scheme is not an easy one to run fluently on Day 1. That means there’s growing pains that come along with a new cast of characters — and the Eagles certainly have faced those pains, netting just six points in their first eight quarters of play. 

Manheim Township 38, Harrisburg 6

Andy Shay: Harrisburg 27, Manheim Township 24: Both squads have come out of the gates flying and executing at a very high level on both sides of the ball. The chess match between the Cougars’ defense and the Blue Streaks’ offense is going to be fascinating to watch play out.

Andy Sandrik: Manheim Township 30, Harrisburg 26: I get the sense that this won’t be the first time these behemoths square off this fall.

Adam Kulikowski: Manheim Township 31, Harrisburg 30: This one is worth the drive for Harrisburg football fans. My crystal ball says we might be getting a preview of a District 3 Class 6A title match later this year.

State College at Hollidaysburg, Canceled

Andy Shay: State College 34, Hollidaysburg 14: Pretty sure the Little Lions are going to be ready to go from the opening whistle this week and focused on getting back on track after watching a late rally fall just short a week ago.

Andy Sandrik: State College 45, Hollidaysburg 21: State College will be fully focused on getting ahead and staying ahead, which could snowball into a blowout loss for Hollidaysburg.

Adam Kulikowski: State College 45, Hollidaysburg 13: The loss to Downingtown East was a mild shock, but don’t let that fool you. The Little Lions are still a force to be reckoned with for any opponent. 

Mechanicsburg 49, Red Land 30

Andy Shay: Red Land 24, Mechanicsburg 21: Toss-up game for me. The Patriots’ run game is a formula for success against the Wildcats’ defense, plus they have a defense that has created some key turnovers. Mechanicsburg offense will be the difference-maker if the Wildcats take this one.

Andy Sandrik: Red Land 21, Mechanicsburg 14: Having that first win under your belt can make a world of difference. The Patriots’ confidence, combined with its running attack and a sprinkle of defense, could serve them well in a grind-it-out kind of game. 

Adam Kulikowski: Red Land 28, Mechanicsburg 20: If the Patriots watched the tape from Cedar Cliff’s victory against Mechanicsburg last Thursday, they likely saw a few tendencies in the passing game that can be exploited against the Wildcats. 

Bishop McDevitt 47, La Salle College 21

Andy Shay: Bishop McDevitt 35, La Salle College 14: A pair of come-from-behind victories against next-level opponents should serve the Crusaders well in this one. I expect this to be close well into the second half before McD takes charge.

Andy Sandrik: Bishop McDevitt 35, La Salle College 10: The star-studded Crusaders have had to fight and claw for everything they’ve gotten in their 2-0 start. That experience will serve them well in this contest. 

Adam Kulikowski: Bishop McDevitt 41, La Salle College 20: Crusaders survived about 20 haymaker shots last week but never toppled. Consider this crew hardened and ready for the final test before division play begins next week. 

Cedar Cliff 43, McCaskey 6

Andy Shay: Cedar Cliff 27, McCaskey 20: There’s a little bit more pop in the Colts’ offense that you might think. They are a patient and efficient unit that will test McCaskey’s defense over the course of 48 minutes.

Andy Sandrik: Cedar Cliff 28, McCaskey 18: Cedar Cliff’s defense has been quietly having a nice little season, but I think they’ll be tested by a McCaskey squad that’s scored a point or two this season.

Adam Kulikowski: Cedar Cliff 41, McCaskey 17: The numbers Cedar Cliff has posted through Week 2 won’t wow you, but that’s just what’s scary about this team. They are getting solid contributions from a wide array of gents.

Hershey 35, Dallastown 19

Andy Shay: Dallastown 28, Hershey 21: Fully aware the Trojans are 2-0 and the Wildcats come into this one licking their wounds, sporting an 0-2 ledger. Who you play also matters, and Dallastown will have a say in the outcome of this game.

Andy Sandrik: Hershey 28, Dallastown 21: Hershey’s been a nice surprise this fall, but sooner or later someone’s going to knock off the Trojans, right? This seems like another 50-50 game, but fortune has favored Hershey in those kinds of contests this fall.

Adam Kulikowski: Hershey 24, Dallastown 21: Wavered on this pick for a few minutes, but I’m settling with the dudes in our coverage area who sport a tidy 2-0 record and a rushing offense that’s averaged a healthy 6.1 yards per carry.

Lower Dauphin 30, Elizabethtown 0

Andy Shay: Lower Dauphin 34, Elizabethtown 7: Bears have lost each of their first two games by 27 points and have struggled to be competitive. Fully healthy, the Falcons should have little trouble posting victory No. 2. 

Andy Sandrik: Lower Dauphin 41, Elizabethtown 14: I’m having more difficulty trying to type “Elizabethtown” than I think LD will actually have with the Bears this week.

Adam Kulikowski: Lower Dauphin 41, Elizabethtown 13: Falcons have the firepower to get some of the youngsters varsity experience in the second half. 

Palmyra 21, at Donegal 14

Andy Shay: Palmyra 28, Donegal 21: At first glance this might appear to be an upset. Not sure I see it that way. The Cougars’ defense has played eight solid quarters, and despite Donegal’s 2-0 mark, I think the 1-1 Cougars are playing their best football.

Andy Sandrik: Donegal 21, Palmyra 14: This has the makings of a defensive-minded contest. Give the edge to the L-L outfit playing at home.

Adam Kulikowski: Donegal 24, Palmyra 14: Give the Cougars credit for hanging tough against an East Pennsboro crew that has had their number in recent seasons. Perhaps it is a bellwether for what is to come in Palmyra, but for me it’s a bit early to bank just yet. 

Susquehanna Township 28, Middletown 13

Andy Shay: Susquehanna Township 35, Middletown 14: This is still a very dangerous ‘Hanna Tribe offense, and the Blue Raiders have already surrendered 79 points this season.

Andy Sandrik: Susquehanna Township 48, Middletown 14: The Middletown rebuild continues, and with ‘Hanna on tap, there’s sure to be more growing pains this week.

Adam Kulikowski: Susquehanna Township 55, Middletown 6: The Indians would be a pristine 2-0 if not for the last-second heroics of Milton Hershey in the season opener. Middletown continues to look for footholds after an idle year on the sidelines. 

East Pennsboro 34, Milton Hershey 28

Andy Shay: Milton Hershey 26, East Pennsboro 21: Nearly half of the 44 meetings (19 to be exact) have been decided by eight or fewer points. All indicators are this battle of 2-0 clubs could be a tight squeeze, as well.

Andy Sandrik: Milton Hershey 28, East Pennsboro 21: I’d rather drink a Grimace Shake than try to figure out this puzzle of a game. I think the Spartans have an edge, but this seems like it could go either way.

Adam Kulikowski: East Pennsboro 24, Milton Hershey 21: Panthers have yet to be fully tested heading into Week 3, but that’s not their fault. The pieces are there with Keith Oates III and some supporting playmakers to challenge in the Colonial Division. And you know the Spartans will make it a grudge match for four quarters — just ask Susquehanna Township. 

Greencastle-Antrim 35, Delone Catholic 21

Andy Shay: Greencastle-Antrim 21, Delone Catholic 14: Blue Devils are a surprising 2-0, and the Squires are struggling defensively and have lost to a pair of quality opponents. This will be a test at the next level for G-A.

Andy Sandrik: Greencastle-Antrim 24, Delone Catholic 12: Greencastle’s stats aren’t completely up to date, but we know the Blue Devils have at least three players who each have at least two sacks. That tells me Greencastle is fully capable of wrecking this game. 

Adam Kulikowski: Greencastle-Antrim 26, Delone Catholic 20: Jury is deliberating just how good the Blue Devils can be in 2023, but let’s not overthink this one. 

Dover 39, Northern 14

Andy Shay: Dover 17, Northern 14: Couple of 1-1 teams that were rolled by big-school opponents a week ago. Big concern for Northern is only three touchdowns scored in eight quarters. Change that, and this contest could easily be a W.

Andy Sandrik: Northern 14, Dover 7: I’m giving Northern the benefit of the doubt, here, but I have some concerns.

Adam Kulikowski: Northern 21, Dover 14: This may have more the feel of a soccer game than football — a game that is likely decided by field position and a key turnover. Both teams have the ability to gain the advantage, but the Polar Bears have the pedigree in recent years. 

Shippensburg 14, Spring Grove 6

Andy Shay: Shippensburg 27, Spring Grove 7: Pretty sure the Greyhounds are less than pleased at having to surrender the Little Brown Jug. This is the right matchup for Ship to steer its season in a new direction. 

Andy Sandrik: Shippensburg 21, Spring Grove 14: The Greyhounds’ offense is still trying to find some traction, so this could be a closer contest than a lot of folks might think.

Adam Kulikowski: Shippensburg 31, Spring Grove 13: The troops from Spring Grove won’t be sending Big Spring party favors anytime soon after the Bulldogs shook the hornet’s nest last week en route to their first victory against Shippensburg in more than a decade. 

Big Spring 47, Newport 0

Andy Shay: Big Spring 26, Newport 7: Bulldogs are on a heater and understand they can’t let the hangover of claiming the Little Brown Jug for the first time since 2010 define their season. Buffaloes’ offensive woes are clear and obvious.

Andy Sandrik: Big Spring 48, Newport 12: I can’t even imagine how big the bonfires were in Newville after Big Spring finally won the big game against the ‘Hounds. Even if the ‘Dogs are a little “hung over” from last week, I still think they have enough studs in the trenches to make life difficult for Newport.

Adam Kulikowski: Big Spring 33, Newport 13: Is there a better feel-good story from Week 2 than the Bulldogs’ victory in the Little Brown Jug game? Those good vibes should continue against a Newport team that is enduring the pain of a rebuild. 

Gettysburg 50, Boiling Springs 14

Andy Shay: Gettysburg 32, Boiling Springs 20: If nothing else the Warriors’ offense has been good enough to be 2-0 instead of 0-2. This game will be determined by how much hay the Bubblers’ offense can make against a struggling Gettysburg defense.

Andy Sandrik: Gettysburg 38, Boiling Springs 14: Boiling Springs would love to slow this game down with its defense and turn this into a low-scoring affair, but I think the Warriors have a little too much pop for that to happen.

Adam Kulikowski: Gettysburg 45, Boiling Springs 20: Gettysburg may be the most dangerous 0-2 team in District 3. But to make any ground in the Colonial, the Warriors are going to need to limit the defensive miscues.

Camp Hill 42, Upper Dauphin 20

Andy Shay: Camp Hill 28, Upper Dauphin 14: When the dust settles around this one, the bottom line is the defense will play a key role in guiding Camp Hill to a 3-0 start. 

Andy Sandrik: Camp Hill 36, Upper Dauphin 21: Austin Duplessie has three sacks in two games for Upper Dauphin from his defensive tackle position. Can he disrupt the Camp Hill passing attack?

Adam Kulikowski: Camp Hill 35, Upper Dauphin 21: For a small school, the Lions always seem to find a young lad who can sling it. They have another in QB Drew Branstetter. The junior’s completion percentage is a hardy 69% (40 of 58 for 549 yards), and he has yet to toss a pick. 

Wyomissing 35, Trinity 34

Andy Shay: Wyomissing 31, Trinity 21: I’m fascinated by this matchup in so many ways. Spartans are the clear favorites, but the T-Rocks have some offensive firepower and the Wyo defense will present a challenge at another level. 

Andy Sandrik: Wyomissing 30, Trinity 21: This is one of those games where I think the Shamrocks need to force a turnover or two to stay within striking distance.

Adam Kulikowski: Wyomissing 38, Trinity 36: To me, this is the biggest prove-it game on the docket for the Shamrocks. We know they are good, but we don’t know yet if they can knock off a perennial District 3 superpower.

West Perry 39, Juniata 21

Andy Shay: West Perry 42, Juniata 7: The Indians have allowed nearly 100 points over eight quarters, and keeping the scoreboard rolling is not a problem at all for the high-octane Mustangs. 

Andy Sandrik: West Perry 51, Juniata 14: The Mustangs are the Perry County champs after routing Susquenita and Newport, and it doesn’t seem like anything is going to stop WP from taking over Juniata County next.

Adam Kulikowski: West Perry 48, Juniata 13: The Mustangs are running like a finely tuned Cobra right now. It isn’t a matter of if they will win, but rather when will they let off the gas. 

Halifax 53, Hancock (Md.) 6

Andy Shay: Hancock 35, Halifax 31: Wildcats are riding high after a convincing 40-0 victory, and the Panthers were blown out in their season opener. Opportunity for Halifax to be 2-1 is right in front of them.

Andy Sandrik: Halifax 36, Hancock 20: It’s so nice to see the Wildcats showing a little pop this season. This is going to be a tough road test, but I’m riding with Halifax.

Adam Kulikowski: Hancock 45, Halifax 20: In my heart, I want to take the Wildcats. But my gut says don’t overvalue the offensive explosion displayed in Week 2.

James Buchanan 21, Biglerville 19

Andy Shay: Biglerville 21, James Buchanan 7: By a slim margin it feels like the Canners have a few more options in terms of offensive weapons. Will say the Rockets’ defense has been up to the task so far, though.

Andy Sandrik: Biglerville 28, James Buchanan 7: In a few months that fall drive through Adams County will be one of the most picturesque trips you can take on a budget. But I don’t think this ride home from Canner Country will be that fun for the Rockets.

Adam Kulikowski: Biglerville 21, James Buchanan 14: The Canners have scored just 21 points in their first eight quarters of play but have a 1-1 record to show for their efforts. Doubling the tally from the first two weeks should be enough to get the dub.

Tri-Valley 23, Line Mountain 14

Andy Shay: Line Mountain 38, Tri-Valley 28: Let the good times roll, right? This has all the ingredients of being a back-and-forth slugfest for a long time despite each squad checking in at 1-1. Throw the records out.

Andy Sandrik: Tri-Valley 27, Line Mountain 24: Coin-flip game, in my mind, but I’ll take the scrappy Bulldogs. Any team whose QB doubles as a DE, like the Bulldogs’ Blake Schwartz (6-6, 190), deserves to be called scrappy. 

Adam Kulikowski: Line Mountain 32, Tri-Valley 31: Last year, the Eagles nearly pulled off a huge upset when they took Tri-Valley to the wire. In some regards, it was the beginning of the awakening of LM. This year, I’m not even sure we would categorize a victory by the home squad as an upset.

Schuylkill Valley 48, Susquenita 14

Andy Shay: Susquenita 27, Schuylkill Valley 21: Give me 6-4, 230-pound Blackhawks QB Derek Gibney and his 500-plus passing yards, six touchdowns and one INT in eight quarters. Shots will be taken is all I know.

Andy Sandrik: Schuylkill Valley 28, Susquenita 20: As a West Perry grad, I’m obligated to pick against the ‘Hawks in a 50-50 game, right? 

Adam Kulikowski: Susquenita 34, Schuylkill Valley 31: The Gibney brothers, Derek and Drew, are taking the backyard pitch-and-catch to new heights this season, connecting 18 times for 236 of QB Derek Gibney’s 527 stripes to date. 

North Schuylkill 48, Pine Grove 0

Andy Shay: North Schuylkill 33, Pine Grove 14: Fully aware each squad is 1-1, just think the Spartans are going to ask some questions of the PG defense that haven’t been asked of them to date.

Andy Sandrik: North Schuylkill 32, Pine Grove 12: I’ve been on the wrong end of some of those 48-6 losses, like the one PG took last week. It’s remarkably hard to get back on track, even if you’re facing an opponent that may otherwise be an even match. 

Adam Kulikowski: North Schuylkill 37, Pine Grove 20: Coming off a week in which Williams Valley gashed the Pine Grove defense for 370 yards, the thought of NS senior running back Jaxson Chowansky and his 7.6 yards per carry (26 carries, 198 yards) likely is keeping the PG defensive coordinator up at night.

Schuylkill Haven 24, Williams Valley 21

Andy Shay: Williams Valley 35, Schuylkill Haven 20: When you have a dude who averages more than 280 yards a game on the ground, that will cover up for a lot of other gaps on your squad.

Andy Sandrik: Williams Valley 44, Schuylkill Haven 9: Folks are buying tickets just to see Alex Achenbach run the ball, and No. 5 is doing it so well that Williams Valley’s hustling defense — which has allowed six points all season — is still an afterthought.

Adam Kulikowski: Williams Valley 45, Schuylkill Haven 13: Last week, Vikings running back Alex Achenbach broke the school rushing record with 343 yards on just 14 carries. Whose record did he break, you might be wondering? His own — 321 yards against Panther Valley in 2021. 

SATURDAY, SEPT. 9

Steel-High 29, West Catholic (Philadelphia) 22

Andy Shay: Steel-High 46, West Catholic 19: While West Catholic is a known name brand in the state, not sure the Burrs have the firepower this season to hold serve against the Rollers. Steel-High is better at putting pressure on teams to play its style of game.

Andy Sandrik: Steel-High 50, West Catholic 13: Rollers are averaging 44 points per contest. I have a feeling that average rises a little bit after this weekend. 

Adam Kulikowski: Steel-High 55, West Catholic 14: West Catholic scored just six points in its season opener last week. That’s simply not enough offensive firepower to contend with Alex Erby and the gents in Steelton. 

Picks and Predictions: Playoffs Week 4

Standings:

Name; Last Week; Overall

Andy Shay:8-2; 188-52

Andy Sandrik: 9-1; 186-54

Adam Kulikowski: 7-3; 181-59

PIAA Class 2A Quarterfinal: 

Steelton-Highspire vs. Southern Columbia at Selinsgrove High School, Friday, November 21, 7

Andy Shay: Southern Columbia 35, Steel-High 21: There is a very, very good reason for more than a decade the Tigers have been considered one of the two or three best overall programs in Pennsylvania. These types of games are the reason. The Rollers will land some punches, but SC counters punches better than most. To boot the Tigers are in peak form.

Andy Sandrik: Southern Columbia 41, Steel-High 28: The Tigers have been on a roll ever since a competitive Week 1 loss to Wyomissing. I want to believe Steel-High can stay in this game, but SC is a legendary program for a reason.

Adam Kulikowski: Southern Columbia 41, Steel-High 30: The Tigers possess three rushers who average more than 6.4 yards-per-carry. That tells me the big eaters up front are busting holes for their backs in dominating fashion. 

PIAA Class 3A Quarterfinal:

Neumann-Goretti vs. Trinity at Exeter Township High School, Friday, November 21, 7

Andy Shay: Trinity 21, Neumann-Goretti 14: This is a very tight matchup and the similarities between these two clubs is spooky. Expect a defensive battle all the way with third down conversion and keeping drives alive as a huge hidden key. If N-G gets to 20-plus points first, they win the game.

Andy Sandrik: Neumann-Goretti 21, Trinity 13: Two top-tier defenses are set to duke it out with a trip to the semifinals on the line. It doesn’t get much better than this.

Adam Kulikowski: Trinity 14, Neumann-Goretti 7: Defense wins championships–or at least will get you to the semifinals. I see this one being decided by one big play. 

PIAA Class 4A Quarterfinal:

Susquehanna Twp. vs. Twin Valley at Eastern Lebanon County High School, Friday, November 21, 7

Andy Shay: Twin Valley 35, Susquehanna Township 14: That was a legendary win by the Tribe over Wyomissing. The drama on winning the game on the last snap will grow in lore as time marches on. Incredible. And the reward is the No. 1 ranked team in the state. Teams are a combined 24-0 so they each know how to win. Remember only a month or so ago the Raiders beat Wyomissing by three touchdowns.

Andy Sandrik: Twin Valley 28, Susquehanna Township 25: For every path to victory I find for ‘Hanna, I find three more for Twin Valley.

Adam Kulikowski: Susquehanna Township 37, Twin Valley 35: These two clubs have been on a collision path for weeks and I doubt they will disappoint. Expect plenty of haymakers to land for each club as this one comes down to the final minutes.  

District 3 5A Championship: 

Solanco vs. Bishop Mcdevitt at Warwick High School, Friday, November 21, 7

Andy Shay: Bishop McDevitt 27, Solanco 20: After two weeks these clubs were a combined 1-3 overall and neither squad has lost a game since. This is a comfort zone game for me. McD stays in that playing from ahead spot they win. Solanco knocks them off their spot and is able to change the tone and tenor they have a huge advantage.

Andy Sandrik: Bishop McDevitt 40, Solanco 17: Few teams are dominating the playoffs in the same way as McDevitt, which has pasted two postseason opponents by a combined 89-7 score. 

Adam Kulikowski: Bishop McDevitt 45, Solanco 14: When I look at this match up, I struggle to see a way Solanco keeps it close for four quarters–and these gents are part of a talented roster. Just my honest opinion. 

District 3 6A Championship: 

Central York vs. Harrisburg at Cedar Cliff High School, Friday, November 21, 7

Andy Shay: Harrisburg 28, Central York 10: Over the course of the last nine games exactly ONE team – Cumberland Valley – has scored more than one touchdown against this Harrisburg defense. This time of year defense and running game matter a LOT and the Cougars excel on both fronts. Also two of the first three teams Harrisburg played to start this season are still around in late November so add battle tested to their arsenal.

Andy Sandrik: Harrisburg 28, Central York 18: I’m not sure if Cougars’ QB Brooklyn Nace has seen the caliber of defense brought to the table by Harrisburg, which has piled up 45 sacks and 17 interceptions this season. 

Adam Kulikowski: Harrisburg 35, Central York 20: Cougars can knock you out in a multitude of ways. Can CY find a way to sustain success against arguably the best defense they’ve faced all season?

PIAA Class 6A Quarterfinal: 

State College vs. Pittsburgh Central Catholic at Mansion Park in Altoona, Friday, November 21, 7

Andy Shay: Pittsburgh Central Catholic 35, State College 21: I fully expect the Little Lions to give a high quality effort that pushes PCC and it still won’t be enough to overcome the Vikings, who are balanced, efficient and are imposing their will on teams as the stakes get higher.

Andy Sandrik: Pittsburgh Central Catholic 42, State College 18: The Vikings have three players with at least eight sacks, including Ashton Blatt, who leads his team with 13.5. With PCC possessing that kind of control over the line of scrimmage, this will most certainly be an uphill battle for the Little Lions.

Adam Kulikowski: Pittsburgh Central Catholic 33. State College 28: I see this as a closer battle than others, but one that every break possible will need to go the Little Lions way to achieve. 

Picks and Predictions: Playoffs Week 3

Standings:

Name; Last Week; Overall

Andy Shay:16-2; 180-50

Andy Sandrik: 15-3; 177-53

Adam Kulikowski: 15-3; 174-56

PIAA Class A First Round: 

Lackawanna Trail 31, Line Mountain 20

Andy Shay: Line Mountain 20, Lackawanna Trail 13: From my chair victory for the Eagles will be centered on a defense that has found a fourth and fifth gear the last couple weeks. In November that matters.

Andy Sandrik: Line Mountain 21, Lackawanna Trail 13: The Eagles picked up some kind of big-time win over Montgomery last week, landing 11.5 tackles for loss in the process. Line Mountain will need more of that to slow down LT running back Isaac Ryon, who has more than 2,600 rushing yards this season.

Adam Kulikowski: Line Mountain 28, Lackawanna Trail 21: Growing up in the Northeastern PA area, I know the pedigree of the Lackawanna Trail program well. Finding space to break loose in this Eagle’s D will test their mettle. 

PIAA Class 2A First Round: 

Steelton-Highspire 52, Chestnut Ridge 20

Andy Shay:  Steel-High 39, Chestnut Ridge 14: All systems are go for the Rollers right now it seems. Formula that will overwhelm CR early and often.

Andy Sandrik: Steelton-Highspire 28, Chestnut Ridge 9: I get the sense that the Lions are a little outgunned in this spot.

Adam Kulikowski: Steelton-Highspire 34, Chestnut Ridge 14: We heard all year that the Rollers are a building program. Looks like the construction has been completed from my vantage point.

District 3 Class 3A:

Berks Catholic vs. Trinity at ELCO High School, Friday, November 14, 7

Andy Shay: Trinity 28, Berks Catholic 14: This will be some old-school high school football at its finest. This will be the T-Rocks’ 13th game of the season and they have surrendered fewer than 150 total points.

Andy Sandrik: Trinity 35, Berks Catholic 27: Trinity RB Brandon Harris came alive last week with a season-high 209 yards. Running the ball and playing hard defense are exactly what the Shamrocks need to do to advance past this round.

Adam Kulikowski: Trinity 24, Berks Catholic 21: That quality defense the ‘Rocks possess will pay huge dividends down the stretch in this tightly contested match up. 

District 3 Class 4A: 

No. 1 Susquehanna Twp. 37, No. 4 Wyomissing 35

Andy Shay: Wyomissing 28, Susquehanna Township 24: Until somebody in District 3 knocks the Spartans off their mountain I refuse to pick against them in this scenario. Indians have ALL the ingredients to make that happen, but picking them is a bridge too far for me.

Andy Sandrik: Susquehanna Township 28, Wyomissing 27: I can’t tell you how many times I’ve been burned on this pick ‘em panel by making the homer pick against Wyomissing in the postseason. This isn’t a homer pick, the Tribe deserve to be favored here.

Adam Kulikowski: Susquehanna Twp. 31, Wyomissing 28: Tribe have the ability to force Wyo into uncomfortable situations if they can stake themselves to an early lead. 

No. 3 Twin Valley 40, No. 2 West York 14

Andy Shay: Twin Valley 49, West York 21: And the score might end up being the closest thing about this one as the Raiders offense is a machine that NOBODY has slowed down.

Andy Sandrik: Twin Valley 48, West York 24: I think West York is in trouble when the Raiders, averaging more than 54 points per game, come into town on Friday.

Adam Kulikowski: Twin Valley 55, West York 21: Until someone can show me a blueprint to stop the Raiders, I’ll take my chances pushing them forward in my bracket. 

District 3 Class 5A: 

No. 4 Solanco 43, No. 1 New Oxford 12

Andy Shay: Solanco 42, New Oxford 28: This will be a two-headed beast of a running attack for Solanco that I’m not sure the No. 1 seeded Colonials have seen or are capable of slowing them down enough to keep up. 

Andy Sandrik: Solanco 35, New Oxford 21: The Golden Mules have two 1,000-yard rushers in Kris Burgos Wise and Johnny Garcia. Can the duo trip up the No. 1-seeded Colonials?

Adam Kulikowski:  New Oxford 28, Solanco 27: Finding a way to slow the Golden Mules aforementioned duo could present a problem, but I see Luke Frey’s ability to get the ball downfield to his playmakers as an underrated weapon.  The senior’s thrown for more than 1,300 yards and has taken care of the rock, committing just two INTs.

No. 3 Bishop McDevitt 42, No. 7 Exeter Township 0

Andy Shay: Bishop McDevitt 42, Exeter Township 14: Just feels to me like a game where the Eagles will need help from the Crusaders to keep in touch. And McD has been very efficient overall for several weeks. 

Andy Sandrik: Bishop McDevitt 35, Exeter Township 21: The Crusaders found another gear last weekend when they crushed a really good Mechanicsburg by 40 points. That’s not great news for Exeter Township.

Adam Kulikowski: Bishop McDevitt 41, Exeter Township 14: Crusaders are playing their best ball of the season when it matters most.

District 3 Class 6A: 

No. 1 Central York 42, No. 4 Wilson 7

Andy Shay: Central York 28, Wilson 22: Something tells me this is a tight squeeze all the way and I’ll take it one step further and say the Panthers come from behind in the second half to keep playing.

Andy Sandrik: Central York 21, Wilson 14: Tough pick, but I think the high-flying Panthers get the job done with QB Brooklyn Nace leading the way.

Adam Kulikowski: Wilson 27, Central York 26: The Bulldogs certainly enter this match up as the underdogs, but we all know the pedigree of the Wilson program and their staff’s ability to maximize its opportunity. 

No. 3 Manheim Township at No. 1 Harrisburg at Harrisburg High School, Saturday, November 15, 1 

Andy Shay: Harrisburg 30, Manheim Township 10: Just hard to see a scenario where the Blue Streaks get the 21 points they need before the fourth quarter to make this a game down the stretch. Cougars defense is LEGIT.

Andy Sandrik: Harrisburg 26, Manheim Township 21: Only one of Harrisburg’s last eight opponents has been able to put up double-digit points against the Cougars. The Blue Streaks will do that, but I think Harrisburg’s defense has the final say in this one.

Adam Kulikowski: Harrisburg 31, Manheim Township 21: Cougars have committed 10 picks in the last six games. That’s playing with fire. Just not sure this is the week turnovers bite HGB.

PIAA 1st Round: 

State College vs. Wilkes-Barre at Milton High School, Saturday, November 15, 1

Andy Shay: State College 34, Wilkes-Barre 21: This will be a challenge for the Little Lions defense for sure. Feels like they have the pieces on defense to make a difference.

Andy Sandrik: State College 32, Wilkes-Barre 28: The Little Lions will be challenged by the skills of Wolfpack QB Jake Howe, who’s piled up nearly 2,600 passing yards and 26 TD passes against eight interceptions.

Adam Kulikowski: State College 35, Wilkes-Barre 17: The Wolfpack’s gunslinger offense could present a new challenge to the Little Lions, from this seat I see a secondary capable of keeping the air attack under wraps. 

Results: Picks and Predictions: Playoffs Week 2

Standings:

Name; Week 10; Overall

Andy Shay:6-6; 164-48

Andy Sandrik: 10-2; 162-50

Adam Kulikowski: 8-4; 159-53

District 3 1A:

No. 1 York Catholic 33, No. 2 Delone Catholic 25

Andy Shay: York Catholic 22, Delone Catholic 20: Never easy to notch two wins over a club in the same season with the gap is next to nothing. Toss up game in my book and I’m leaning Fighting Irish to nudge across the finish line.

Andy Sandrik: Delone Catholic 21, York Catholic 14: The last meeting between these teams saw the Fighting Irish win a close game. Can the Squires return the favor? 

Adam Kulikowski: Delone Catholic 24, York Catholic 20: In tight games like this one is expected to be, taking care of the rock can be the difference. Give that edge to the Squires. 

District 3 1A: 

No. 1 Line Mountain 20, No. 2 Montgomery 14

Andy Shay: Montgomery 21, Line Mountain 14: Will take a special outing by the LM offense to flip my script. Defense matters in November and Montgomery has a strong one that will ask some fresh questions of the Eagles.

Andy Sandrik: Line Mountain 28, Montgomery 21: The Red Raiders have only allowed double-digit point totals twice this season. Line Mountain can win this game, but it will need to play a clean game on offense and defend like crazy.

Adam Kulikowski: Montgomery 20, Line Mountain 7: A quick look at the Eagles schedule tells me they haven’t faced a defensive unit like they are squaring up to bout this Friday. Mistake free football is a must for this score to turn in LM’s favor. 

District 3 2A:

No. 1 Steelton-Highspire 52, No. 2 Halifax 13

Andy Shay: Steelton-Highspire 40, Halifax 20: How can you not like the Rollers who already own a three-touchdown win over the Wildcats? Yes, that game was very early in the season, still that’s a big gap to close. Any chance for Halifax rides on the heels of its defense.

Andy Sandrik: Steelton-Highspire 33, Halifax 24: The Rollers already own a win over the Wildcats and deserve to be favored here, but it wouldn’t surprise me at all if Halifax puts a scare into Steel-High.

Adam Kulikowski: Steelton-Highspire 38, Halifax 31: I see this one being close right down to the wire. Yes, I know the Rollers cruised early in the season, but this Wildcats crew has evolved. 

District 3 3A: 

No. 1 Berks Catholic 37, No 4 Bermudian Springs 6

Andy Shay: Berks Catholic 34, Bermudian Springs 20: When the Saints get rolling downhill they come at you in waves on the ground and just continue to pound. Eagles can score, but can their defense get off the field enough to keep up. 

Andy Sandrik: Berks Catholic 37, Bermudian Springs 21: Berks Catholic has four backs with more than 500 rushing yards and another who is close to breaking through that barrier. It’s no secret what the Saints will try to do on Friday.

Adam Kulikowski: Berks Catholic 45, Bermudian Springs 14: We all know how the Saints will attack you on offense, but Bermudian will want to account for linebacker Faith Zudie as a behind-the-line ball hawk. Zudie leads the Saints with 18 tackles for loss. 

No. 3 Trinity 42, No. 2 Annville-Cleona 21

Andy Shay: Trinity 31, Annville-Cleona 7: This will be the strongest defense A-C has faced this season and for sure the Shamrocks have faced more diverse and powerful offenses along the way.

Andy Sandrik: Trinity 34, Annville-Cleona 12: I guess this is technically calling for an upset since A-C carries the higher seed, but Trinity has the defense to make this a miserable night for the Dutchmen.

Adam Kulikowski: Trinity 37, Annville-Cleona 14: Don’t look at the seeding. Shamrocks hold the cards in this one and should be considered the favorite.

District 3 4A: 

No. 1 Susquehanna Twp. 50, No. 9 ELCO 13

Andy Shay: Susquehanna Township 35, Elco 7: Simply put the Indians have way too much firepower for ELCO.

Andy Sandrik: Susquehanna Township 42, ELCO 9: You don’t want to overlook any team, especially in the postseason, but it’s hard to envision this game ending in a way that isn’t a blowout victory for ‘Hanna.

Adam Kulikowski: Susquehanna Township 48, ELCO 14: Hanna has its eyes on a District title. Not sure ELCO will have a say in preventing the Tribe from marching onward.

No. 5 Lampeter-Strasburg at No. 4 Wyomissing, Saturday, November 8 at Wyomissing High School, 1 p.m.

Andy Shay: Wyomissing 42, Lampeter-Strasburg 21: Why do I feel a three-score difference for the Spartans might not be enough? Wyomissing operates at another clinical level.

Andy Sandrik: Wyomissing 41, Lampeter-Strasburg 14: No offense to the Pioneers, who seem to be a perennial contender in the district playoffs, but Wyomissing was 41 points better than L-S in the last week of the regular season.

Adam Kulikowski: Wyomissing 38, Lampeter-Strasburg 14: Recency bias will tell you to predict a wider margin of victory after these two clubs squared off at the end of the regular season, but the Pioneers have enough weapons to keep this interesting into the second half. 

No. 2 West York 20, No. 10 Middletown 0

Andy Shay: West York 21, Middletown 6: Any No. 10 seed still fighting the early sunset to get practices in would be a welcome bonus. The Blue Raiders traveled the hard road to get this shot and will not be an easy out.

Andy Sandrik: West York 28, Middletown 7: This is a tough matchup for Middletown, but win or lose, what a sweet ride it’s been for the Blue Raiders this season.

Adam Kulikowski:West York 35, Middletown 14: The Bulldogs are loaded with young talent. Their 2,300-yard passer? A sophomore. Their top rusher? A sophomore. Four of their top six receivers? Sophomores. This is a team we’ll be talking more about in the coming years.

No. 3 Twin Valley 49, No. 6 West Perry 15

Andy Shay: Twin Valley 41, West Perry 7: There are some holes West Perry can’t hide from a team that thrives on a combination of its own strengths and weapons and has the coaching staff that is keen at exploiting opponents’ weaknesses.

Andy Sandrik: Twin Valley 33, West Perry 10: The average score for a Twin Valley game this season has been 54-8 in favor of the Raiders. The Mustangs certainly face an uphill battle to keep their season alive.

Adam Kulikowski: Twin Valley 34, West Perry 24: Mustangs enter this one as a clear underdog, but if there’s one thing we know about Bob Boden-led teams, it’s that they will fight and claw until the final buzzer.

District 6 4A:

No. 2 Bellefonte 17, No. 1 Juniata 6

Andy Shay: Bellefonte 22, Juniata 21: Dare I say give me Bellefonte in overtime winning on a two-point try? The Raiders’ schedule has been a gauntlet that has prepared them for a big-game win.

Andy Sandrik: Juniata 21, Bellefonte 17: This game seems like a coin flip all the way. I’m giving a slight edge to Jasper Shepps and the Indians.

Adam Kulikowski: Juniata 24, Bellefonte 17: Expect this one to be won in the trenches with these two squads fighting for every yard.

District 3 5A: 

No. 1 New Oxford 31, No. 8 Spring Grove 26

Andy Shay: New Oxford 21, Spring Grove 14: This feels like a dog fight all the way where the little things will become magnified – turnovers, penalties, etc. – and the winner isn’t decided until the dying minutes. Colonials survive.

Andy Sandrik: New Oxford 24, Spring Grove 13: I don’t know if New Oxford has that “unstoppable” aura that comes with being a No. 1 seed, but I do think the Colonials survive at least one more round.

Adam Kulikowski: New Oxford 28, Spring Grove 21: The Colonials senior-laden team isn’t ready quite yet for their undefeated season to come to an end. Experience matters in the big moments. 

No. 4 Solanco 56, No. 5 Warwick 24

Andy Shay: Solanco 28, Warwick 7: I feel strongly the Indians will push back more the second time around, however over the course of 48 minutes the Golden Mules are the better team and that will show up.

Andy Sandrik: Solanco 28, Warwick 14: How much can Warwick close the gap on Solanco after taking a 35-7 whipping from the Golden Mules in Week 4? 

Adam Kulikowski: Solanco 31, Warwick 20:  Solanco is an overtime loss to Lampeter-Strasburg in Week 1 away from running the table this year. And they don’t hide what’s gotten them to this point–blugeoning their opponents on the ground. 

No. 7 Exeter Township 41, No. 2 Conestoga Valley 34

Andy Shay: Conestoga Valley 28, Exeter Township 21: I like the diversity of the CV offense, the only question is can they force the Eagles outside their comfort zone and make them throw the ball more than they want. I say yes.

Andy Sandrik: Conestoga Valley 24, Exeter Township 17: If Conestoga Valley can find a way to slow down 2,000-yard RB Leomar Brown and force the Eagles to pass, the Buckskins have a capable secondary that’s picked off 15 passes this season.

Adam Kulikowski: Exeter Township 24, Conestoga Valley 21: Exeter isn’t your typical No. 7-seed. If they get ahead early, they have the ability to control the clock and limit CV’s opportunities.

No. 3 Bishop McDevitt 47, No. 6 Mechanicsburg 7

Andy Shay: Bishop McDevitt 35, Mechanicsburg 7: Tough draw for the Wildcats, whose defense will be tested at another level they haven’t yet experienced. End of the day the mismatch comes when Wildcats have the ball and McD is playing defense.

Andy Sandrik: Bishop McDevitt 33, Mechanicsburg 14: It’s going to take some kind of breakout performance from the Wildcats to keep this game within reach. I think McDevitt’s defense has the final say in this one.

Adam Kulikowski: Bishop McDevitt 38, Mechanicsburg 14: Crusaders simply have too many options on the table to reach its desired destination. 

District 3 6A: 

No. 1 Central York 42, No. 8 Cedar Cliff 7

Andy Shay: Central York 42, Cedar Cliff 17: If you play secondary for the Colts buckle up because your head is going to be on a swivel this week against a CY passing attack that has layers.

Andy Sandrik: Central York 42, Cedar Cliff 25: Cedar Cliff hasn’t faced an opposing QB with the chops of Panthers’ signal-caller Brooklyn Nace, who’s compiled more than 2,300 yards and 29 TDs, against just one interception.

Adam Kulikowski: Central York 45, Cedar Cliff 20: While Brooklyn Nace gets plenty of attention for all the reasons my colleagues mentioned, give props to Legend Johnson who is averaging 8.5 yards per carry en route to nearly 1,000 stripes this season. 

No. 4 Wilson 28, No. 5 William Penn 14

Andy Shay: Wilson 35, William Penn 7: All I know is the Bulldogs defense has allowed only three touchdowns over the last 12 quarters. See where I’m going in this one?

Andy Sandrik: Wilson 42, William Penn 21: Although York doesn’t have a bad resume, my gut tells me that Wilson surges to a comfortable victory.

Adam Kulikowski: Wilson 38, William Penn 14: If you’re York’s coaching staff preparing for this match up, I have my eyes on limiting the damage the Bulldog’s  No. 44,  EJ Brownback inflicts. The stud linebacker has a team-high 97 tackles on the season–nearly double any other Bulldog’s output. 

No. 10 Central Dauphin at No. 2 Harrisburg, Saturday, November 8 at Harrisburg High School, 1 p.m.

Andy Shay: Harrisburg 35, Central Dauphin 7: Hey, the Rams showed up two weeks ago and held the Cougars offense to four touchdowns. Big problem was CD was shut out the Harrisburg defense. Not much has changed in those 21 days.

Andy Sandrik: Harrisburg 42, Central Dauphin 15: The Rams took a big step forward as a program this season not only by fielding a competitive squad in the rugged Commonwealth Division, but also by securing a playoff win over rival Cumberland Valley last week. All good things, however, come to an end.

Adam Kulikowski: Harrisburg 48, Central Dauphin 21: Tip of the proverbial cap to Coach Mac’s crew for a job well done this season. Reaching the postseason was already a success and advancing past CV was the cherry on top. 

No. 3 Manheim Township 49, No. 6 Hempfield 7

Andy Shay: Manheim Township 35, Hempfield 14: Blue Streaks are on a heater and that firepower on offense will make Hempfield very uncomfortable early and often.

Andy Sandrik: Manheim Township 28, Hempfield 18: The last time these teams met in Week 5, Blue Streaks’ QB Jack Kenneff lit up Hempfield for 300 yards and three TD passes. 

Adam Kulikowski: Manheim Township 34, Hempfield 20:  The Blue Streaks are… well…. Streaking heading into this matchup as winners of eight straight. Make it nine in a row Friday.

Results: Picks and Predictions: Playoffs Week 1

Standings:

Name; Week 10; Overall

Andy Shay: 15-4; 158-42

Andy Sandrik: 13-6; 152-48

Adam Kulikowski: 15-4; 151-49

District 3 2A: 

No. 1 Steel-High 46, No. 4 Columbia 22

Andy Shay: Steel-High 41, Columbia 7: That foregone given that the Rollers would feature a dynamic and lethal offensive attack as in the recent past was not on the table this year. Steel-High has worked and developed into a team that demands you keep pace on the scoreboard.

Andy Sandrik: Steel-High 35, Columbia 14: The Rollers have been clicking on all cylinders for several weeks, now. I’m not sure how Columbia can slow down this speeding train.

Adam Kulikowski: Steel-High 31, Columbia 20: Rollers enter the postseason on a four-game hot streak. Columbia will provide a better test than the Rollers endured the last few weeks, but this is a squad ready for battle. 

No. 2 Halifax 30, No. 3 Lancaster Catholic 14

Andy Shay: Lancaster Catholic 27, Halifax 25: I’m fairly certain the red-hot Wildcats will have the two best players on the field offensively. Just need to see if the rise from the ashes this season by Halifax has any legs at the next level.

Andy Sandrik: Halifax 27, Lancaster Catholic 24: Halifax has found a rhythm during its six-game winning streak. Teagan Carroll and Cohen Bechtel, two backs who have combined for nearly 30 rushing and receiving TDs, have a lot to do with that.

Adam Kulikowski: Halifax 33, Lancaster Catholic 28:  After a winless season in 2024, anything this Wildcats team accomplishes in the postseason is icing on an already stellar season. That doesn’t mean the boys from Halifax are content with their accomplishments.

District 3 3A: 

No. 3 Trinity 35, No. 6 Schuylkill Valley 7

Andy Shay: Trinity 27, Schuylkill Valley 7: Defense wins championships and travels well in the second season and it’s been a while since I can recall a smaller school defense that was this dominant on a weekly basis.

Andy Sandrik: Trinity 30, Schuylkill Valley 7: Few teams have been a tougher out than Trinity this fall. Make it eight wins in nine weeks for the ‘Rocks.

Adam Kulikowski: Trinity 31, Schuylkill Valley 13: By this time you should be well versed on the prowess of the ‘Rocks’ defense, but give credit to the gents on offense who will keep you off kilter with their balanced attack.

No. 4 Bermudian Springs 25, No. 5 Big Spring 24

Andy Shay: Big Spring 30, Bermudian Springs 22: There is HOPE in the greater Newville area with the return of one Grady Hope to the Bulldogs lineup for the final regular season game. He moves the needle, changes the game, alters the outcome … etc. He is THAT player for Big Spring.

Andy Sandrik: Big Spring 34, Bermudian Springs 24: Big Spring got a big boost last week with Grady Hope’s return to the lineup, and I think the Bulldogs’ schedule has them a little more prepared for this moment.  

Adam Kulikowski: Big Spring 28, Bermudian Springs 21: The afore mentioned return of Grady Hope makes the Bulldogs a favorite in my eyes, but one X-factor that can tip the tides is Bermudian’s Brayden Heller. The 5-11 senior wideout possesses big play ability in the passing game and has the ability to knock the top off the Bulldog defense. 

District 3 4A: 

No. 10 Middletown 21, No. 7 Eastern York 19

Andy Shay: Eastern York 15, Middletown 13: I like what the Blue Raiders bring to the table in terms of dogged grit, however offensively I think they are a small fry short of a Happy Meal in this matchup.

Andy Sandrik: Middletown 19, Eastern York 15: I’m still not sure who will win this game, but I do know that Middletown won’t get caught off guard. The Blue Raiders simply find ways to stay competitive with even the toughest of opponents.

Adam Kulikowski: Eastern York 21, Middletown 14: Eastern York has the potential to do damage through the air in this match with gunslinger Quinn Bramble racking up nearly 2,000 yards this season.

No. 9 ELCO 28, No. 8 Kennard-Dale 21

Andy Shay: ELCO 29, Kennard-Dale 19: Tails was ELCO.

Andy Sandrik: ELCO 33, Kennard-Dale 17: The Raiders have rallied behind QB Brinley Donmoyer to qualify for the postseason after a 1-4 start. I think the comeback tour continues for ELCO, at least for one more week.

Adam Kulikowski: ELCO 34, Kennard-Dale 27: ELCO surrenders points at an alarming rate–30 per game average. Just not sure the Rams have the weapons on offense to take full advantage of the opportunities available.

District 3 5A: 

No. 5 Warwick 23, No. 12 Shippensburg 7

Andy Shay: Warwick 27, Shippensburg 14: All I know is the Warriors will ask the Greyhounds to find another level to match them and when that’s been the case this season Ship hasn’t had the tools in the chest to answer that call.

Andy Sandrik: Warwick 24, Shippensburg 18: Too many good wins on Warwick’s resume to hazard picking against the Warriors.

Adam Kulikowski: Warwick 28, Shippensburg 7: Warwick’s stout defense makes this a tough pull for a Shippensburg team with an offense that isn’t elite. 

No. 6 Mechanicsburg 35, No. 11 Red Land 21

Andy Shay: Mechanicsburg 17, Red Land 10: First of all WTHeck is this matchup. Sometimes I hate numbers. This will be a defensive tussle and the Wildcats have the more impactful defense at this level.

Andy Sandrik: Mechanicsburg 21, Red Land 7: The Wildcats’ defense has been locked in for several weeks now. Red Land can win, but it will be an uphill battle.

Adam Kulikowski: Mechanicsburg 21, Red Land 20: The Patriots proved a month ago when these two squads faced off that they were not to be taken lightly. While it is a winnable game for the Patriots, I see the Wildcats as the favorite. 

No. 7 Exeter Township 35, No. 10 Lower Dauphin 0

Andy Shay: Exeter Township 34, Lower Dauphin 14: All I know is Exeter is NOT a No. 7 seed, they are a snake in the grass falling this far with an 8-2 record and those two losses being by a combined total of six points. Brutal draw for the Falcons who have risen up from a bumbling start to playing its best football right now. BRUTAL!

Andy Sandrik: Exeter Township 23, Lower Dauphin 16: I feel dirty picking against the Falcons, who have done nothing but get better on a week-to-week basis, but the Eagles are a top-tier squad that finished six points shy of an unbeaten season.

Adam Kulikowski: Exeter Township 31, Lower Dauphin 21: Terrible match up for a Falcons team plays its best football now. Will take every break going their way to knock of Exeter.

No. 9 Muhlenburg vs. No. 8 Spring Grove, Friday , October 31 at Spring Grove High School

Andy Shay: Muhlenburg 26, Spring Grove 24: I’m going with the chalk on this one.

Andy Sandrik: Spring Grove 21, Muhlenberg 17: The Rockets have three backs that have piled up 17 rushing TDs. This group does not include senior QB Davis Baum, who has run for five scores of his own, and thrown for 12 more.

Adam Kulikowski: Muhlenburg 34, Spring Grove 21: Muhls’s powerhouse offense will have a big say in how competitive this game stays through four quarters. 

District 3 6A: 

No. 10 Central Dauphin 7, No. 7 Cumberland Valley 6

Andy Shay: Cumberland Valley 24, Central Dauphin 14: Second bite of the apple for the Rams against the Eagles after the earlier meeting this season was competitive. CV defense is better now than it was the first month. That’s the difference maker.

Andy Sandrik: Cumberland Valley 28, Central Dauphin 14: The longer CV can hang around in the postseason, the better the Eagles’ elite defense can thrive in cold outdoor conditions. 

Adam Kulikowski: Cumberland Valley 21, Central Dauphin 14: My colleagues said it and I agree, CV defense will be the deciding factor. 

No. 8 Cedar Cliff 35, No. 9 Cedar Crest 6

Andy Shay: Cedar Crest 27, Cedar Cliff 21: That was some football badness the Colts displayed on defense in week 10 surrendering 48 points to a Cumberland Valley offense that has scored fewer than 40 points in the previous 12 quarters combined. I like the CC running back but taking the Falcons.

Andy Sandrik: Cedar Cliff 28, Cedar Crest 21: I like what I’m seeing from Crest’s 1,000-yard RB Isaiah Zimmerman,  who is averaging 9.3 yards per carry, but I think the Commonwealth Division grind has the Colts well prepared for this moment.

Adam Kulikowski: Cedar Cliff 31, Cedar Crest 14: The Colts enter this fray battle tested through a grueling Commonwealth Division schedule. Those bumps might have hurt, but the dividends should be evident in the Colts second season.

Vote now: Week 10 Mid-Penn Conference Player of the Week

Vote now for our 4th Down Magazine Mid-Penn Conference Player of the Week. Our poll will remain open until Wednesday evening at 11 p.m. Voting is allowed once every 30 minutes.

Editor’s note: We have implemented safeguards to prevent voting which falls outside the spirit of the rules in place. We reserve the right to block users who cast fraudulent votes.

Jaxon Tyree, RB, Northern York: In his final game at the high school level, senior Jaxon Tyree turned in a stellar performance to lead the Polar Bears to the team’s sole victory of the season, 22-21 against Palmyra. On a game-high 31 carries, Tyree erupted for 191 yards—including a 99-yard touchdown.

Hunter Strohm, RB, Lower Dauphin: With a playoff berth on the line, the Falcons turned to their ground attack to knock off Gettysburg, 35-15. Strohm led the way scoring four touchdowns on a hardy 11.4 yards per tote average to finish the evening with 228 yards on 20 carries.

Ayden Martinez, WR, Big Spring: When the Bulldogs needed a big play to keep their playoff hopes alive, Martinez came down with the big catch. The junior hauled in five receptions for a game-high 118 yards and a touchdown in a 31-21 victory against East Pennsboro.

Jerome Ross III, RB, Steel-High: The Roller’s Ross III exploded for a monster night Friday against Newport. Ross scorched the Buffs for 307 yards on 23 carries. He added three rushing touchdowns including a 99-yarder and also returned a kickoff 80 yards to pay dirt in a 46-30 victory.

This poll has ended (since 22 days).
Hunter Strohm, RB, Lower Dauphin:
82.83%
Ayden Martinez, WR, Big Spring:
8.08%
Jerome Ross III, RB, Steel-High:
5.05%
Jaxon Tyree, RB, Northern York:
4.04%

Results: Week 10 Picks and Predictions

Standings:

Name; Week 9; Overall

Andy Shay 18-1; 143-38

Andy Sandrik: 18-1; 139-42

Adam Kulikowski 17-2; 136-45

Cumberland Valley 48, Cedar Cliff 17

Andy Shay: Cumberland Valley 14, Cedar Cliff 7: I’m very conflicted about this game on many levels. Overall I think right now the Colts are playing better football, but the CV defense has been locked in at another level the last month. Taking a flyer on the Eagles here.

Andy Sandrik: Cedar Cliff 17, Cumberland Valley 14: It usually takes me just a short while to go through each of these picks, but I’ve been staring at the monitor for this one for several minutes now. I’m going with the Colts solely for the reason of playing catchup to AShay in the 4DM pick ‘em standings. 

Adam Kulikowski: Cumberland Valley 24, Cedar Cliff 21: On a defense that has been stout all season, Zayden Smith has been a ball hawk, picking off four passes this season. While the Eagle’s offense has struggled at times, players like Smith have the potential to make a game-changing impact.

Mechanicsburg 17, Shippensburg 0

Andy Shay: Mechanicsburg 20, Shippensburg 7: Both squads have close wins over a solid Hershey team as my measuring stick. Again I’m going with the defensive unit of the Wildcats that is playing lights out surrendering one or fewer touchdowns in three of their last four games. That’s not an accident.

Andy Sandrik: Mechanicsburg 21, Shippensburg 14: The Greyhounds have been a tough squad on a weekly basis, but not exactly an offensive juggernaut. Points will come at a premium against this Mechanicsburg defense, and I get the sense it will take some kind of game-altering play, perhaps on special teams, for Ship to get over the hump.

Adam Kulikowski: Mechanicsburg 28, Shippensburg 21: Two quality programs square off. Give the edge to the Wildcats who I see as the more balanced club.

Steel-High 46, Newport 30

Andy Shay: Steel-High 39, Newport 7: Two ships headed in opposite directions. Rollers have been stacking wins and the Buffs are stacking losses after an awesome first half.

Andy Sandrik: Steel-High 41, Newport 10: The Buffs need this win badly but it’s hard to pick against the Rollers, whose only two losses have come to undefeated teams.

Adam Kulikowski: Steel-High 45, Newport 17: Ending the season on a five game skid isn’t the way the Buffs want to go into the season. But the reality is this program has made serious strides forward in ‘25. That’s what this crew should take into the offseason.

Central Dauphin 28, Chambersburg 20

Andy Shay: Central Dauphin 14, Chambersburg 7: To me these two teams are very similar. They are a small fry short of a Happy Meal on the talent front, but are not easy to beat and give you their very best shot. Intriguing matchup.

Andy Sandrik: Chambersburg 16, Central Dauphin 10: I’m taking a bit of a gamble on Chambersburg, but the Trojans have plenty of motivation with a playoff spot on the line.

Adam Kulikowski: Central Dauphin 21, Chambersburg 14: When you play the three top teams in the Commonwealth Division over the last four weeks, you welcome an opportunity to play a team on more level footing. Rams take advantage. 

James Buchanan 8, Camp Hill 6

Andy Shay: James Buchanan 30, Camp Hill 20: I would love to pick the Lions to get a win this season but as much as my old man softie heart wants the lads wearing blue to get that victory feeling, football-wise it seems a bridge too far.

Andy Sandrik: James Buchanan 28, Camp Hill 14: As tough of a season as it’s been for the winless Lions, no football program in Pennsylvania understands suffering more than the James Buchanan Rockets. Some of that decades-long pain will be alleviated when JB earns its third win on Friday.

Adam Kulikowski: James Buchanan 35, Camp Hill 14: Rockets wrap up a competitive regular season with its third victory while the Lions turn in their helmets in search of answers this offseason. 

Bishop McDevitt 36, State College 20

Andy Shay: State College 27, Bishop McDevitt 24: When I took the scattered puzzle pieces and put it together I found ways to make it work where each team was the better one. So this is just a feeling I have that State College has a little more of the “right stuff” for this matchup to isolate a slight weakness or two the Crusaders possess. Very slight weaknesses I might add.

Andy Sandrik: Bishop McDevitt 35, State College 28: At some point these 7-2 Crusaders are going to get tired of being referred to as a vulnerable team in a down season. McDevitt has a great opportunity to set the record straight when it welcomes SC into Rocco Ortenzio Stadium. 

Adam Kulikowski:  State College 31, Bishop McDevitt 24: Little Lions appear to be a more healthy team heading into this division clash of titans. Doesn’t mean it will be a cruiser.

Northern York 22, Palmyra 21

Andy Shay: Palmyra 29, Northern York 7: When the playing field is nearly level or the Cougars have an edge or two they win those games. And they have not been an easy team to beat.

Andy Sandrik: Palmyra 34, Northern 14: Last chance for the Polar Bears to get in the win column, but Palmyra has been a tough out for all.

Adam Kulikowski: Palmyra 33, Northern York 6: Five of the last six Palmyra games have been decided by one score. If that’s the case in Week 10, tip your cap to the Polar Bears. 

Altoona 31, Carlisle 21

Andy Shay: Altoona 32, Carlisle 13: Mountain Lions have a couple wins and been competitive for the most part despite their record. Carlisle has neither of those and has surrendered 49 or more points in four of its last five games.

Andy Sandrik: Altoona 28, Carlisle 21: Life is not easy for any team in the Commonwealth Division, especially the ones that are bringing up the rear. After taking lumps from the big dogs of the division, I get the sense both the Mountain Lions and Thundering Herd will be eager to compete against someone their own size on Friday.

Adam Kulikowski: Altoona 33, Carlisle 13: This is a nine out of 10 on the confidence meter selection. Mountain Lions have the tools to create separation as both teams look to wrap up the season on a high note.

West Perry 31, Greencastle-Antrim 13

Andy Shay: West Perry 33, Greencastle-Antrim 20: All I know is West Perry has two losses to Trinity and Susquehanna Township. Mustangs have won all the others. That works for me.

Andy Sandrik: West Perry 28, Greencastle-Antrim 21: The Blue Devils were left for dead after a 1-5 start to the season, but they’ve bounced back and now have an outside shot of qualifying for the playoffs if they can find a way to knock off WP. Mustangs will have to play a clean game to outlast motivated Greencastle. 

Adam Kulikowski: West Perry 41, Greencastle-Antrim 24: Both teams have plenty to play for as we wrap up the regular season. Mustangs possess a level of grit and fight that’s admirable.

Lower Dauphin 35, Gettysburg 14

Andy Shay: Lower Dauphin 37, Gettysburg 14: The Falcons are my MPC building block team of 2025. They were battered and bruised early and started from a deep hole and have just kept grinding and digging to put it back together. And the offense has now scored 35 or more points in each of their last three games. Warriors can’t keep up with that.

Andy Sandrik: Lower Dauphin 42, Gettysburg 20: The Falcons have worked way too hard to claw their way back into the playoff picture to let it all slip away now.

Adam Kulikowski: Lower Dauphin 33, Gettysburg 24: Warriors haven’t won a ball game since mid-September while the Falcons have an opportunity to play an 11th game this season.

Mifflin County 21, Red Land 15

Andy Shay: Red Land 27, Mifflin County 20: This won’t be easy for the Patriots and that’s okay. Closing out an eight-win season after years and years of struggling should be hard because the hard is what makes it great. MC is playing its best football of the season. 

Andy Sandrik: Red Land 23, Mifflin County 17: Red Land’s 5-0 start was nice, but what’s impressed me the most is how the Patriots have bounced back from the two tough losses that came after that streak. Red Land will once again face adversity against Mifflin County, but now we know the Patriots are fully equipped to ride out the storm.

Adam Kulikowski: Mifflin County 28, Red Land 27: The Huskies certainly enter this match up as an underdog, but if you’re going to take a shot on a dog, why not one that’s on a bit of a heater?

Juniata 14, Upper Dauphin 7

Andy Shay: Juniata 23, Upper Dauphin 19: Two straight losses for Juniata vs. four straight wins for Upper Dauphin. I see you Trojans. Yet I’m still taking the reliable Indians. 

Andy Sandrik: Upper Dauphin 28, Juniata 14: Momentum, coupled with a sense of urgency, can be an incredible thing. The Trojans – on a four-game winning streak and sitting one spot outside of the district playoff picture – have plenty of both. 

Adam Kulikowski: Upper Dauphin 27, Juniata 21: The fact that the Trojans even have a shot at reaching the postseason after starting the season 0-5 says a lot about the leadership on and off the field in UD. 

Big Spring 31, East Pennsboro 21

Andy Shay: East Pennsboro 24, Big Spring 14: Both these teams are right on the playoff bubble in their respective PIAA District 3 classes. So there’s a lot at stake. Bulldogs are sliding and Panthers run hot and cold. Trade paint boys!

Andy Sandrik: East Pennsboro 21, Big Spring 17: The Panthers and Bulldogs both started the season with 4-1 records, but it’s looking more and more like the loser of this game could miss the playoffs.

Adam Kulikowski: East Pennsboro 31, Big Spring 24: All eyes will be on this tussle to see who can secure that coveted playoff berth.

Line Mountain 63, Susquenita 14

Andy Shay: Line Mountain 42, Susquenita 6: The last time the Blackhawks scored more than two touchdowns in a game was Week 1. Eagles will cruise into the postseason.

Andy Sandrik: Line Mountain 61, Susquenita 7: The Eagles have surpassed 60 points twice this season against quality programs in Newport and Halifax. Make it three times when LM visits Cove on Friday night.

Adam Kulikowski: Line Mountain 58, Susquenita 7: Eagles get one final tune up before the postseason kicks off. 

Hershey 29, Waynesboro 16

Andy Shay: Hershey 38, Waynesboro 7: Two of the Trojans’ three losses were by three points and one of those was in OT. The other is a 7-0 defeat to Mechanicsburg last week. In other words they are a bit better than their 6-3 record.

Andy Sandrik: Hershey 35, Waynesboro 14: As good as Hershey has been this season, it still sits one spot outside of the 12-team, District 3-5A playoff picture. Needless to say, this is a must-win game for Cam Sweeney and the Trojans.

Adam Kulikowski: Hershey 43, Waynesboro 7:  There’s simply no way the Trojans don’t take care of their business with a district playoff berth on the line. 

Trinity 28, Middletown 27

Andy Shay: Trinity 20, Middletown 0: Only Susquehanna Township last week cracked the 20-point barrier on the T-Rocks defense this season. That’s all I have to say about that, really.

Andy Sandrik: Trinity 14, Middletown 7: The Blue Raiders have been punching above their weight class all season and I think they’ll be in this game until the end. Trinity’s defense, however, will have the last say.

Adam Kulikowski: Trinity 28, Middletown 7: When your team gives up less than 10 points per game, you’re going to win your share of games. 

Halifax 52, Boiling Springs 20

Andy Shay: Halifax 42, Boiling Springs 6: Not only did the Wildcats beat Juniata last week, they thumped the Indians convincingly. Win No. 7 for Halifax is on deck.

Andy Sandrik: Halifax 39, Boiling Springs 14: A victory on Friday would give Halifax more wins in 2025 than the last four years combined.

Adam Kulikowski: Halifax 43, Boiling Springs 6: After tossing four picks in a blowout loss to Line Mountain, Wildcats quarterback Ryder Tobias has tossed just one in the last four outings. That’s what turning a corner looks like. 

Saturday, October 25

Harrisburg 28, CD East 6

Andy Shay: Harrisburg 28, CD East 7: They like to say funny things happen when these two teams square off. And some of it might still happen. And for the Panthers it still won’t be near enough to slay this giant.

Andy Sandrik: Harrisburg 35, CD East 6: After a long layoff Messiah Mickens returned to the Harrisburg lineup last week. The live reps from this game will go a long way toward fine-tuning Mickens for what could be a deep postseason run. 

Adam Kulikowski: Harrisburg 42, CD East 7: Cougars do what they need to do to ensure their key players are as ready for the postseason as possible. 

Susquehanna Twp. 49, at Milton Hershey 16

Andy Shay: Susquehanna Township 42, Milton Hershey 14: Time to put a bow on that perfect regular season for the Hanna Tribe. Make sure to take time to celebrate appropriately before moving on because 10-0 isn’t as easy as it looks … EVER!

Andy Sandrik: Susquehanna Twp. 44, Milton Hershey 7: Milton Hershey’s defense has shown some improvement over the back half of the season, but the Spartans will have their hands full against a ‘Hanna team putting up more than 40 points per game. The Tribe roll to 10-0.

Adam Kulikowski: Susquehanna Twp. 55, Milton Hershey 14: Tip of the cap to Joe Headen and this talented gaggle of young lads who put behind them undeserved offseason turmoil and will rip off an undefeated regular season with a victory in Week 10. 

Results: Week 9 Picks and Predications

Andy Shay 16-3; 125-37

Andy Sandrik: 13-6; 121-41

Adam Kulikowski 14-5; 119-43

Bishop McDevitt 49, CD East 7

Andy Shay: Bishop McDevitt 42, CD East 0: Doesn’t get any easier for the Panthers, who are on a four-game slide and struggling to put points on the board. McD is playing arguably its most solid ball of the season these days.

Andy Sandrik: Bishop McDevitt 37, CD East 7: The Crusaders got a good push from Central Dauphin last week. Not sure the same can be expected from the Rams’ intra-district counterpart at East.

Adam Kulikowski: Bishop McDevitt 49, CD East 7: Crusaders simply are on another level from their Harrisburg counterpart.

Greencastle-Antrim 26, Boiling Springs 13

Andy Shay: Greencastle-Antrim 35, Boiling Springs 7: Make it three in a row for the surging Blue Devils after that one-point upset of Juniata last week. 

Andy Sandrik: Greencastle-Antrim 42, Boiling Springs 16: The Blue Devils have found a rhythm behind the running of RB Blake Reuter, who has a good chance to record his fourth 100-yard game in six weeks.

Adam Kulikowski: Greencastle-Antrim 33, Boiling Springs 13: While the Bubblers didn’t win last week, the team did score a season-high 21 points. Sometimes progress isn’t measured in wins and losses.

Cumberland Valley 7, Chambersburg 0

Andy Shay: Cumberland Valley 27, Chambersburg 7: Full credit to the Eagles for giving the Cougars 60 minutes of their very best a week ago. As long as that effort doesn’t come with a heavy price, expect the Eagles to perform well against a Trojans squad that has won two straight.

Andy Sandrik: Cumberland Valley 14, Chambersburg 7: I was this close to taking the surging Trojans, who actually rank ahead of CV in the district power rankings, but then I remembered the elite defensive unit possessed by the Eagles. It’s that defense that should make the difference in what I expect to be a tightly-contested game.

Adam Kulikowski:  Cumberland Valley 21, Chambersburg 14: The Eagles showed plenty of potential last week against powerhouse Harrisburg, but taking the Trojans lightly would be unwise. 

West Perry 27, Milton Hershey 20

Andy Shay: West Perry 30, Milton Hershey 16: Feel like a game where the Mustangs have to mind their P’s & Q’s and don’t get caught napping cause the Spartans have huge holes but have also won two straight. The better team is West Perry.

Andy Sandrik: West Perry 34, Milton Hershey 14: After a winless start to the season, the Spartans have been playing confident football in recent weeks. West Perry, however, represents a big jump in competition from what Milton Hershey has seen in recent weeks. 

Adam Kulikowski: West Perry 41, Milton Hershey 21: The Mustangs match up well with the Spartans defense which is yielding 30 points per game on average.

State College 58, Carlisle 8

Andy Shay: State College 42, Carlisle 0: That’s just the way it is this season for the Thundering Herd.

Andy Sandrik: State College 44, Carlisle 7: If you’re a Carlisle fan, it was encouraging to see the Herd erupt for 19 points last week after managing just 14 over the first seven games combined. There are signs of life in Carlisle, but it will take much more than that to knock out this heavyweight of the Commonwealth Division.

Adam Kulikowski:  State College 55, Carlisle 6: No one likes to make predictions like this, but the Thundering Herd are a crew building for next season in Week 9.

Lower Dauphin 41, Waynesboro 17

Andy Shay: Lower Dauphin 34, Waynesboro 20: Remember when the Falcons were 0-2 and we were all wondering what was going on. Five wins in six games later – the only loss was by a FG to Shippensburg – and LD has put its stake in the playoff seeking ground.

Andy Sandrik: Lower Dauphin 36, Waynesboro 18: I really like the grit of this LD team, which keeps coming back no matter how hard it gets punched in the mouth. This resilience has turned into momentum for the Falcons, who now have a great opportunity to win for the sixth time in seven weeks.

Adam Kulikowski: Lower Dauphin 28, Waynesboro 21: Half of the Falcons games have been decided by one score or less. Don’t expect LD to be flustered by a tight battle. 

Line Mountain. 49, Camp Hill 13

Andy Shay: Line Mountain 49, Camp Hill 7: The winless Lions have surrendered 43 or more points in all but one game. It’s hard to remain competitive with those numbers. Eagles roll. 

Andy Sandrik: Line Mountain 48, Camp Hill 0: A true David vs. Goliath matchup when the 0-8 Lions visit the 8-0 Eagles. It’s going to take much more than a small stone, however, for Camp Hill to slay this giant.

Adam Kulikowski: Line Mountain 45, Camp Hill 13: Lions defense has been susceptible to giving up chunk plays all season. Expect the Eagles to take full advantage.

Susquehanna Twp. 24, Trinity 14

Andy Shay: Susquehanna Township 21, Trinity 13: This is the matchup we’ve all waited for because it’s so crystal clear that it’s all about the Hanna Tribe high-octane offense vs. the T-Rocks stingy defense. Three touchdowns is the number I see as enough for the Tribe. It will NOT be easy to get there, though.

Andy Sandrik: Susquehanna Township 28, Trinity 21: I expect a close contest, but I’ll take the turbo-charged Tribe offense over the stout Trinity defense. 

Adam Kulikowski:  Susquehanna Twp. 24, Trinity 21: Look, if anyone can knock off the Tribe, I think the Shamrocks pose a huge threat. Having said that, the Tribe are the favorites coming in and should be treated as such. 

Halifax 32, Juniata 7

Andy Shay: Halifax 22, Juniata 21: Why do I already regret making this pick. But I’m gonna ride the Wildcats defense to be a difference maker and stick to my guns.

Andy Sandrik: Juniata 24, Halifax 18: I think Juniata’s loss to a run-based Greencastle squad may actually pay dividends this week in a crucial Capital Division tilt with Halifax, another team that thrives on running the ball.

Adam Kulikowski: Juniata 28, Halifax 21: The Wildcats enter this fray on a four game heater–surrendering no more than 13 points per game during the streak. Indians raise the bar on the level of competition this week. 

Steel-High 52, Susquenita 8

Andy Shay: Steel-High 46, Susquenita 0: Find me a bad loss on the Rollers schedule. This is still the best small-school team in District 3 by a long shot. And the Blackhawks have exactly one touchdown the last 12 quarters. 

Andy Sandrik: Steel-High 36, Susquenita 0: With everything going on around Steelton – the least concerning of which is the lack of a true home field for the Rollers – you have to appreciate how well Andrew Erby’s squad has rolled with the punches and stayed locked in this fall.

Adam Kulikowski: Steel-High 41, Susquenita 7: I’m predicting a late ‘Nita touchdown to break that 12-quarter scoreless streak. The outcome, however, is not in question.

Shippensburg 28, Northern York 7

Andy Shay: Shippensburg 31, Northern York 0: Pretty sure there will be some extra fire in the Greyhounds’ belly after taking one on the chin from Red Land. Clear the Polar Bears are starting over this season under new management.

Andy Sandrik: Shippensburg 28, Northern York 7: A Mid-Penn insider once told me that Eric Foust-coached Ship teams never lose back-to-back games. There’s some truth to that, as the Hounds have experienced losing streaks in just three of the last 10 seasons.

Adam Kulikowski: Shippensburg 34, Northern York 6: Not sure what is happening inside the walls of the Polar Bears complex, but it’s clear this is a team rebuilding. 

East Pennsboro 24, James Buchanan 0

Andy Shay: East Pennsboro 28, James Buchanan 14: Been a rough ride for these Panthers, who have dropped three straight by a touchdown or less each time. That ends in this one to inch a game over the .500 mark.

Andy Sandrik: East Pennsboro 35, James Buchanan 13: You’ve got to feel for this JB squad that has had one of its more competitive seasons in recent history, but only has two wins to show for it. Breaking out of a six-game losing streak will be an uphill battle for the Rockets against a quality East Penn side that is eager to snap its own losing skid.

Adam Kulikowski: East Pennsboro  31, James Buchanan 24: A few different bounces and we’re talking about a Panthers team that is 7-1 heading into this Week 9 tussle.  Panthers feel more equipped to snap their 3-game skid.

Cedar Cliff 28, Altoona 6

Andy Shay: Cedar Cliff 28, Altoona 3: Points have really dried up for Altoona, and the Colts just seem to have more pieces of the puzzle.

Andy Sandrik: Cedar Cliff 30, Altoona 17: With a 4-4 record the Colts sit comfortably at No. 6 in the District 3-6A  power rankings. Winning this game, a contest Cedar Cliff is favored to win, will only improve the playoff landscape for the Colts.

Adam Kulikowski:  Cedar Cliff 34, Altoona 14: There’s a bulletin board in Altoona somewhere that these picks get pinned up on. I simply see more options for the Colts to win than the Mountain Lions.

Upper Dauphin 35, Newport 14

Andy Shay: Newport 29, Upper Dauphin 26: I expect this one to be a tight squeeze all the way in a clear toss-up game in my book. 

Andy Sandrik: Upper Dauphin 28, Newport 21: The Trojans are winners of three straight, but extending that streak to four games against the Buffs will be a difficult assignment. This appears to be a 50-50 game, but I’m rolling with UD because of the momentum and home-field advantage.

Adam Kulikowski: Upper Dauphin 34, Newport 27: It took the Trojans four weeks of play to score 21 points. Over the last four weeks, UD’s offense has scored no less than 35. While strength of opponents is a factor, it’s clear the Trojans have found a rhythm. 

Red Land 22, Palmyra 13

Andy Shay: Red Land 28, Palmyra 14: Granting the Cougars have over performed this season and have every right to feel good about where they climbed to this season. Red Land is simply the overall better team and that still matters.

Andy Sandrik: Red Land 24, Palmyra 18: I think I’m back on the Red Land bandwagon after the Patriots’ convincing win over Shippensburg. A win over a much-improved Palmyra squad is expected, but won’t be easy. 

Adam Kulikowski: Red Land 21, Palmyra 14: If anyone was wondering if the shine wore off the Patriots after two straight loses, the answer was a resounding no. Just ask Shippensburg.

Mechanicsburg 7, Hershey 0

Andy Shay: Mechanicsburg 28, Hershey 21: Give me the Wildcats defense against one of the more explosive and elusive quarterbacks in the MPC. Key for Mechanicsburg will be the offense just doing its part.

Andy Sandrik: Mechanicsburg 38, Hershey 28: Classic matchup of Man vs. Machine, with the man being Hershey QB Cam Sweeney and the machine being Mechanicsburg, particularly the Wildcats’ defense.

Adam Kulikowski: Hershey 31, Mechanicsburg 28: Would this truly be considered an upset? Trojans posses the biggest X-factor in the game and a supporting cast that won’t allow Mechanicsburg to sell out to stop HIM (Cam Sweeney). 

Middletown 20, Big Spring 17

Andy Shay: Middletown 14, Big Spring 10: All I know is when you play the Blue Raiders you better show up because what they lack in overall talent gets more than made up for in next level grit and effort.

Andy Sandrik: Middletown 18, Big Spring 14: I’m unclear on the extent of Grady Hope’s injury, but I do know the Bulldogs have gone 1-2 since his departure from the lineup. Middletown may have turned the corner after a big win over East Pennsboro.

Adam Kulikowski: Middletown 21, Big Spring 20: Recency bias is a dangerous beast, but I’m tempting fate here after the Blue Raiders took care of East Penn last week in what might have been the team’s best win of the season. 

Mifflin County 34, Gettysburg 21

Andy Shay: Mifflin County 37, Gettysburg 21: Two ships heading in opposite directions as they cross paths with MC running white hot and the Warriors on a slide in the wrong direction. Ahhhhh the ebbs and flows of a season.

Andy Sandrik: Mifflin County 33, Gettysburg 28: With three wins over the last four games, the Huskies have a little more traction and confidence than the Warriors, who are trying to snap a four-game losing streak.

Adam Kulikowski: Mifflin County 41, Gettysburg 31: Difference to me in this one is a Warriors defense who is yielding more than 30 points per game this season. Plenty of opportunities for the Huskies to light up the scoreboard.

Saturday, October 18, 1

Harrisburg 27, Central Dauphin 0

Andy Shay: Harrisburg 33, Central Dauphin 14: Cougars will ask questions of the Rams they simply are not capable of answering this season over the course of 48 minutes. CD will require Harrisburg to earn what it gets, though. Easy street is closed.

Andy Sandrik: Harrisburg 32, Central Dauphin 18: CD put up quite the fight with Bishop McDevitt last weekend. It’s good to see the Rams making a return toward being competitive in the Commonwealth, but I think they’re just a few pieces short to knock off the big dogs in the division.

Adam Kulikowski: Harrisburg 41, Central Dauphin 21: Coach Cal will want to see the Cougars play a clean four quarters after turning the ball over far too many times last week. Accomplish that mission and Harrisburg should continue its undefeated season.  

Vote Now: Week 8 Mid-Penn Conference Player of the Week

Vote now for our 4th Down Magazine Mid-Penn Conference Player of the Week. Our poll will remain open until Wednesday evening at 11 p.m. Voting is allowed once every 30 minutes.

Editor’s note: We have implemented safeguards to prevent voting which falls outside the spirit of the rules in place. We reserve the right to block users who cast fraudulent votes.

Nate Rawlings, LB, Gettysburg: In a back and forth battle that produced more than 70 combined points, Rawlings was a force who Palmyra needed to account for on every play. The junior racked up 18 total tackles on the evening in a 43-35 loss to the Cougars.

Bryan Maduena, WR, Hershey: Maduena proved to be Cam Sweeney’s favorite target Friday night against Northern York. The senior hauled in six receptions—including a 51-yard touchdown—for 134 stripes to help fuel a 42-14 victory against the Polar Bears.

D’Antae Sheffey, RB, State College: Sheffey turned in a workhorse performance Friday night against CD East in a 39-7 victory. The senior toted the rock 24 times for 183 yards and four touchdowns to help his team cruise to an easy victory.

Cam Green, QB, Chambersburg: The Trojans’ sophomore quarterback has been coming up huge for his team recently. After firing the only touchdown pass against Carlisle last week, Green made his presence known against Altoona on 13 of 18 passing for 173 and three touchdowns in a 28-10 victory against the Mountain Lions.

Nickayus Zenon, WR, Middletown: In a tight game, Zenon connect on the home run from quarterback Harrison Ortiz in a 14-10 victory against East Pennsboro. Zenon secured a game-high 170 yards receiving on eight receptions, including a 79-yard touchdown—one of two on the evening.

Torin Evans, QB, Susquehanna Twp.: Evans almost needs a standing place in our player of the week nominations. But even for him, is Week 8 performance stood out. Evans sliced up the Big Spring defense for a whopping 419 yards on 29 of 41 passing and four touchdowns in a 42-13 victory. Not too shabby.

This poll has ended (since 1 month).
Nate Rawlings, LB, Gettysburg:
71.35%
Torin Evans, QB, Susquehanna Twp.:
21.64%
Cam Green, QB, Chambersburg:
6.30%
Nickayus Zenon, WR, Middletown:
0.37%
D’Antae Sheffey, RB, State College:
0.17%
Bryan Maduena, WR, Hershey:
0.17%

Week 7 Mid-Penn Conference Player of the Week: Ryder Tobias

Ryder Tobias delivered a Week 7 victory for his team and the Halifax fans rewarded his efforts with more than 2,200 votes to claim our Mid-Penn Conference Player of the Week honor.

He narrowly defeated Susquehanna Twp. running back Rakhi Seville for the top honor.

Tobias was a model of efficiency in a 27-2 victory against Susquenita in Week 7. The senior gunslinger completed 85.7 percent of his passes—a smooth 12-of-14 passing—for 181 yards.

Results: Week 8 Picks and Predictions

Standings:

Name; Week 7; Overall

Andy Shay 16-3; 109-34

Andy Sandrik: 17-2; 108-35

Adam Kulikowski 15-4; 105-38

Thursday, October 9

Milton Hershey 49, Boiling Springs 21

Andy Shay: Milton Hershey 33, Boiling Springs 13: Bubblers simply can’t keep anybody from making the scoreboard click over at a consistent pace. Spartans get their crack at win No. 2 this week.

Andy Sandrik: Milton Hershey 35, Boiling Springs 14: The Bubblers haven’t been in a close game since their Week 1 win over Littlestown. They’ll have more opportunities against the one-win Spartans, but that street goes both ways, and I think Milton Hershey’s offense will make a difference in this game.

Adam Kulikowski: Milton Hershey 35, Boiling Springs 7: While the Spartans have faced their own struggles this season, their offense has shown potential. That should be enough to get win No. 2 this week. 

Harrisburg 21, Cumberland Valley 16

Andy Shay: Harrisburg 35, Cumberland Valley 7: And l think the Eagles have a pretty good defense. That tells you what the Cougars have cooking this season.

Andy Sandrik: Harrisburg 28, Cumberland Valley 10: After surrendering a loss to CV at Severance Field last year, Harrisburg will come into this game looking to make an example out of the Eagles. 

Adam Kulikowski: Harrisburg 35, Cumberland Valley 17: The only teams to truly challenge the Cougars were fellow juggernauts State College and Bishop McDevitt. Not sure the Eagles have the pieces to rise to that level.

Line Mountain 54, James Buchanan 8

Andy Shay: Line Mountain 45, James Buchanan 13: There’s a little gut check in this undefeated Line Mountain team that is going to be unleashed on the Rockets.

Andy Sandrik: Line Mountain 38, James Buchanan 12: The Eagles have won their last two games by a total of three points. Look for unbeaten LM to win by much more than against the slumping Rockets.

Adam Kulikowski: Line Mountain 41, James Buchanan 14: After two back-to-back nail biters in which the Eagles won by a combined three points, Eagles should have a more comfortable match up this week. 

Middletown 14, East Pennsboro 10

Andy Shay: East Pennsboro 21, Middletown 14: Counting on the Panthers hitting on a couple explosive plays to offset the Blue Raiders defense. Big time toss up game for me.

Andy Sandrik: East Pennsboro 24, Middletown 17: Both squads have had their share of heartbreak over these last few weeks. The team that can best keep its head and roll with the punches will be the one that comes out on top.

Adam Kulikowski: East Pennsboro 28, Middletown 21: Coaches love to talk about creating explosive plays. Well, the Panthers created three, including a pair of 80-yard touchdown receptions last week in a narrow loss to division-leading Susquehanna Twp and six more the week before against West Perry. Can the Blue Raiders keep the Panther’s powder dry? .

State College 39, CD East 14

Andy Shay: State College 44, CD East 7: Too much depth on the offensive weapons depth chart for the Panthers to handle.

Andy Sandrik: State College 41, CD East 14: There are just too many ways that State College can do damage for me to predict a close game. Sophomore Connor Kulka continues to impress with 18 TDs against just two INTs.

Adam Kulikowski: State College 48, CD East 14:  Little Lions running back D’Antae Sheffey has an excellent opportunity to reach 1,000 rushing yards on the season this week despite missing a week of action. The senior needs just 127 stripes to reach the milestone. 

Bishop McDevitt 48, Central Dauphin 21

Andy Shay: Bishop McDevitt 35, Central Dauphin 7: I’m looking for the McD defense to be a difference maker in this one against a Rams squad that will battle but that’s about the best it can muster.

Andy Sandrik: Bishop McDevitt 35, Central Dauphin 14: I’m sure Central Dauphin, a tougher squad now than in recent years, will take a lot of pride in giving McDevitt its best effort. But even if the Rams fire on all cylinders, it’s hard to imagine them holding serve with the Crusaders for four full quarters.

Adam Kulikowski:Bishop McDevitt 45, Central Dauphin 20: Crusaders unleash a three-headed monster in the backfield each week with Nazir Jones-Davis, Jerome Larue and Maurice Barnes each averaging more than 5.6 yards per carry. 

Cedar Cliff 57, Carlisle 19

Andy Shay: Cedar Cliff 42, Carlisle 7: Get your points and work in you need to get done and call off the dogs. It costs nothing to be football nice to a struggling opponent.

Andy Sandrik: Cedar Cliff 34, Carlisle 7: The Colts will be expected to win this game comfortably, if not by mercy rule. 

Adam Kulikowski: Cedar Cliff 45, Carlisle 6: The Colts have to be happy to see Carlisle on the docket this week against running through alligator ally over the last month. 

Halifax 23, Newport 0

Andy Shay: Newport 29, Halifax 28: There is not logical reason for this pick other than too many fruity drinks in the 50th state the last few weeks. Halifax is the favorite but give me the Buffs.

Andy Sandrik: Halifax 28, Newport 17: A matchup of two teams that could possibly meet in the District 3-2A postseason. I’ll go with the surging Wildcats for this contest.

Adam Kulikowski: Halifax 34, Newport 28: Two resurgent teams square off in this one–now that’s a feel-good story! Wildcats seem to have a few more weapons at their disposal. 

Susquehanna Twp. 35, Big Spring 6

Andy Shay: Susquehanna Township 35, Big Spring 14: Hasn’t been as easy for the Tribe the last couple weeks, but stacking wins is what matters and the pictures of how they look are for everybody else to decide through their own lens. All I know is Big Spring is good and won’t have a say in the outcome.

Andy Sandrik: Susquehanna Twp. 39, Big Spring 18: As good as the Bulldogs have been as a team this season, I’m not certain they have the individual personnel to match up with the star-studded tribe.

Adam Kulikowski: Susquehanna Twp. 41, Big Spring 14: Are the Tribe angry that they had to fight for four quarters against East Pennsboro last week to earn their victory? I see a resharpened effort from Coach Headen’s crew this week.  

Chambersburg 28, Altoona 10

Andy Shay: Chambersburg 34, Altoona 30: In a matchup where the offense for both teams has been MIA more than an asset this season, why not pick a shootout with a little crazy final result.

Andy Sandrik: Altoona 35, Chambersburg 28: Offense has been hard to come by for both teams this season, so let’s make an unhinged prediction and call for a shootout at Mansion Park on Friday.

Adam Kulikowski: Altoona 28, Chambersburg 14: Every time I pick against the Mountain Lions, I get a look of disdain from my wife–an Altoona alum. Not this week! 

Steel-High 26, Camp Hill 12

Andy Shay: Steel-High 54, Camp Hill 7: This simply won’t be a level playing field or a fair fight. That’s how it’s playing out this season for the Rollers and Lions.

Andy Sandrik: Steel-High 49, Camp Hill 7: The Rollers are scoring over 30 points a game, while the Lions are allowing more than 40 per night. All signs point to a Steel-High blowout win.

Adam Kulikowski: Steel-High 55, Camp Hill 6: Tough to see this one staying within striking distance for the Lions. Rollers dictate what the final score looks like. 

Upper Dauphin 38, Susquenita 7

Andy Shay: Upper Dauphin 30, Susquenita 20: Head down to your local bowling alley and watch a ringer fire off a turkey – three strikes in a row. That will match the win streak UDA is about to post.

Andy Sandrik: Upper Dauphin 32, Susquenita 18: Just when we thought the UD program was in a complete freefall this season, the Trojans have clawed back with a two-game winning streak. Make that three games after this week.

Adam Kulikowski: Upper Dauphin 45, Susquenita 7: It took the Trojans some time, but UD’s troops have found their footing in the season’s second half. That momentum continues for another sennight.

Hershey 42, Northern York 14

Andy Shay: Hershey 40, Northern York 7: When you have trouble keeping up on the scoreboard and the visiting team has a bona-fide start at QB that spells all kinds of trouble for the home lads from Dillsburg.

Andy Sandrik: Hershey 30, Northern York 7: As a writer for the Dillsburg Banner who’s been following these Northern kids since they were Smurfs, this season has been a tough watch. The script shows no signs of flipping against Cam Sweeney and the Trojans.

Adam Kulikowski: Hershey 38, Northern York 6: Polar Bears have eclipsed the 20-point mark on offense just twice this season. 

Red Land 23, Shippensburg 7

Andy Shay: Red Land 29, Shippensburg 27: Why not, right? Fully aware the Patriots are on a two-game slide after that stellar 5-0 start. They are still playing good ball and that matters. Ship is the favorite and has earned that.

Andy Sandrik: Shippensburg 28, Red Land 21: The Greyhounds have had a knack for winning close games this season and have an unbeaten record in the Keystone to show for it. Can they keep the ship sailing?

Adam Kulikowski: Shippensburg 35, Red Land 24: Patriots dropped its last two match ups against some of the best competition faced all year. Sledding doesn’t get any easier against Shippensburg in Week 8.

Trinity 38, West Perry 14

Andy Shay: Trinity 14, West Perry 7: I just don’t think the Mustangs offense has enough horsepower to get two touchdowns on this T-Rocks defense. If they score two or more TD’s the chances of winning increase greatly.

Andy Sandrik: West Perry 17, Trinity 13: I’m a WP football alumni, so it’s not out of the ordinary to see me side with the Mustangs in 50-50 games. But this Trinity defense, which has allowed an average of four points per game during the Shamrocks’ five-game winning streak, has me concerned.

Adam Kulikowski: Trinity 21, West Perry 20: Trinity is riding a five-game winning streak in which they’ve allowed no more than 8 points in a game. 

Greencastle-Antrim 21, Juniata 20

Andy Shay: Juniata 34, Greencastle-Antrim 13: The spit and fire the Blue Devils will bring to the table won’t phase the Indians one little bit.

Andy Sandrik: Juniata 24, Greencastle-Antrim 21: Yes, the Blue Devils are a two-win team and yes, Juniata is confident right now. But Greencastle is a step up in competition from what the Indians have seen in recent weeks, and if they overlook that, it could cost them the game.

Adam Kulikowski: Juniata 33, Greencastle-Antrim 14: This match up looks a lot closer if aliens abduct Jasper Shepps. But barring extraterrestrial intervention, Shepps is an absolute game wrecker in all facets of the game.

Lower Dauphin 35, Mifflin County 26

Andy Shay: Lower Dauphin 26, Mifflin County 13: The way LD has been building from the early-season ashes has been impressive. Will take their best to keep rolling as MC brings a little extra to the table that could wobble the Falcons.

Andy Sandrik: Lower Dauphin 23, Mifflin County 12: The Falcons, coming off their best offensive and defensive showing of the season, are in a great spot to win for the fourth time in five weeks.

Adam Kulikowski: Lower Dauphin 24, Mifflin County 7: The Falcons are winners of their last four of five games and they done it as a unit, getting contributions up and down their roster.

Mechanicsburg 32, Waynesboro 17

Andy Shay: Mechanicsburg 30, Waynesboro 7: Wildcats stay grounded and take care of what is right in front of them as they prepare for the heavy lifting that’s going to be required in the final two weeks. Defense wins this one in my book.

Andy Sandrik: Mechanicsburg 32, Waynesboro 10: If the Wildcats don’t get caught looking ahead to Hershey and Shippensburg, they’ve got enough talent on both sides of the ball to win this one comfortably.

Adam Kulikowski: Mechanicsburg 35, Waynesboro 14:  Not going to overthink this one. All signs point to Mechanicsburg handling the Indians without a major issue.

Saturday, October 11

Palmyra 43, Gettysburg 35

Andy Shay: Gettysburg 27, Palmyra 18: Warriors have been kicked around a bit the last three weeks on a playing field that wasn’t level. This one is more balanced and I see some matchup advantages I like that put the Cougars in a tough spot.

Andy Sandrik: Gettysburg 25, Palmyra 18: This feels like a coin-flip game, but something tells me Preston Burnett and the Warriors’ offense can scrape together enough points to pull away from Palmyra.

Adam Kulikowski: Gettysburg 28, Palmyra 21: After back-to-back weeks yielding at least 47 points, Gettysburg looks to find its footing defensively. Palmyra provides an opportunity.